Ground Improvement, Rigid Inclusions
Rigid Inclusions vs. Deep Foundations for Heavy-Load Structures
November 5, 2026
You’re planning a heavy building, like a distribution center, an industrial facility, or a multi-story residential building. The soil report comes back showing soft clay, loose fill, or soil that changes a lot across the site. The first reaction is often, “We’re going to need piles.” Sometimes that’s right, but it’s worth checking whether another option fits first.
Rigid inclusions are a ground improvement method that can sometimes take the place of a deep foundation. Rigid inclusions are unreinforced concrete columns installed through soft or compressible soil into stronger soil below. A layer of compacted gravel, called a load transfer platform, goes on top. The columns carry loads through the weak soil into stronger layers below, which can let the structure sit on regular shallow footings and a slab-on-grade.
Deep foundations take a different approach. They’re structural systems that carry the building’s loads past the weak soil to stronger soil or rock far below the surface. Both can work under heavy loads. The right choice depends on the soil, the loads, and what the project needs. This article walks through how to tell the difference.
What’s the difference between rigid inclusions and deep foundations?
The biggest difference is how each system carries the load.
With a deep foundation, structural systems transfer the building’s loads to stronger soil or rock far below the surface. CNC’s deep foundation systems include helical piles, which are screw-like steel elements, and micropiles, which are small-diameter, high-capacity grouted piles.
With rigid inclusions, the columns improve the ground instead. They sit below a gravel load transfer platform, and the footings sit on top of that platform. The columns transfer loads through the weak soil into stronger layers, which can allow the structure to be supported on shallow footings without over-excavation or a full deep foundation system. That’s why CNC treats rigid inclusions as ground improvement, even though the columns may extend well below the surface.
| Rigid inclusions | Deep foundations | |
| System type | Ground improvement | Deep foundation |
| How load is carried | Columns beneath a gravel load transfer platform transfer loads through weak soil into stronger layers | Structural systems transfer loads to stronger soil or rock far below the surface |
| What it allows | Shallow footings and slabs-on-grade on soil that couldn’t support them before | Support when surface soils lack the strength for shallow footings |
| How CNC installs them | Displacement tooling, such as displacement augers or vibratory pipes, with minimal spoils and limited vibration | Varies by system: helical piles screw in with minimal vibration, and micropiles are small-diameter grouted piles |
| Common uses | Warehouses, industrial slabs, tanks, embankments, retaining walls | Weak surface soils, very heavy loads, tight sites, and underpinning existing structures |
You can learn more about CNC Foundations’ rigid inclusion capabilities or explore our deep foundation services.
When can rigid inclusions replace piles?
Rigid inclusions may be worth evaluating instead of a deep foundation when several of these are true:
- The soft soil has firmer soil below it at a reachable depth. The columns need something solid to transfer load into.
- The design could use regular footings and a slab if settlement were controlled. That’s the main payoff: keeping a shallow foundation on soil that couldn’t support one before.
- Vibration needs to stay low. CNC installs rigid inclusions with displacement tooling, which limits vibration and makes the system suitable for sensitive sites and projects next to existing structures.
- Spoils are a problem. Displacement tooling installs the columns without removing the existing soil, so there’s less cleanup and haul-off.
Rigid inclusions can allow a structure to be supported without over-excavation or a full deep foundation system. Whether that saves money or time depends on the project, and it should be checked against a deep foundation option rather than assumed. On some CNC projects, the project team found that deep foundations were not cost-effective for that site, which is what led them to rigid inclusions.
For a deeper look at how rigid inclusions handle bearing capacity and settlement, read when rigid inclusions fit high-load commercial building projects.
When is a deep foundation the better choice?
Rigid inclusions aren’t the answer for every heavy-load project. A deep foundation may be the better fit when:
- An existing structure needs underpinning. Helical piles, for example, are well suited to underpinning existing structures.
- Site constraints rule out other approaches. Property lines, limited access, or tight jobsites can make a deep foundation the more practical choice. Micropiles, for example, are suited to restricted access areas.
What does this look like on real projects?
Industrial: Chelsea Point, Winthrop, Massachusetts. This 135,000-square-foot industrial facility near Logan International Airport needed to support heavy industrial loads on a site with highly variable, compressible soils, including uncontrolled fill and soft organic marine silt and clay. Traditional deep foundation options were cost-prohibitive, and the project needed a low-vibration approach that could meet strict settlement limits. CNC installed more than 1,900 rigid inclusions with a reverse flight displacement auger, topped with a granular load transfer platform. The system controlled settlement within design tolerances and removed the need for deep foundations or extensive excavation. See how rigid inclusions supported the Chelsea Point industrial facility.
Multifamily: Riverchase, Nashville, Tennessee. This 139,392-square-foot multifamily building sat on soft lean clay with trace organics, with bedrock depths varying from 25 to 50 feet and potential karst geology. Rather than using deep foundations, CNC installed more than 1,200 rigid inclusions under a load transfer platform, which allowed shallow footings on soil that couldn’t support them before. The displacement auger limited spoils in a constrained urban site, and the design also aimed to reduce long-term risks related to the karst. Read the Riverchase multifamily case study.
Mixed conditions: Gaston Commerce Center, Gastonia, North Carolina. Some sites don’t need a single answer. To support heavy MSE walls for an industrial development with highly variable soils, CNC used aggregate piers in zones with moderate soil strength and rigid inclusions in areas with soft or highly compressible soils and higher loads.
All three projects were completed on schedule, with testing confirming they met their design requirements. Read the Gaston Commerce Center case study.
What should you evaluate before choosing?
The choice between rigid inclusions and a deep foundation comes down to the site. Before deciding, the team should have:
- Soil borings that go through the soft layers and into the firmer soil or rock below
- Column loads, slab loads, and the structural engineer’s settlement limits
- Known subsurface risks, like uncontrolled fill, organic soils, debris, or karst
- Site limits, such as nearby buildings, vibration limits, access, and where excavated soil can go
Bring in a specialty geotechnical contractor before the foundation type is locked in. A GC or developer may assume piles are needed, and sometimes they are. Getting an early review means rigid inclusions can be fairly compared against a deep foundation while the design can still change.
CNC Foundations has worked as a design-build geotechnical contractor since 1987, with in-house engineers, union field crews, and company-owned rigs. Because CNC offers both ground improvement and deep foundation systems, the preconstruction review looks at the geotechnical report, safety conditions, and constructability for both options. If a deep foundation isn’t the right fit, the team will recommend a ground improvement system instead.
Evaluating foundation options for an upcoming project? The right approach starts with understanding the soil conditions, loading requirements, and project constraints. Connect with your local Business Development Manager to talk through your site.
Turn on screen reader support
To enable screen reader support, press Ctrl+Alt+Z To learn about keyboard shortcuts, press Ctrl+slash



